HomeWinBuzzer NewsGoogle Faces Billion-Dollar Lawsuit over Tensor Processing Unit (TPU) Patents

Google Faces Billion-Dollar Lawsuit over Tensor Processing Unit (TPU) Patents

A courthouse in Massachusetts is playing host to a high-stakes TPU patent battle between tech giants Google and Singular Computing.


A jury trial has commenced against technology giant Google, following accusations from Singular Computing that the search company's Tensor Processing Units, or TPUs, were created using proprietary designs developed by Singular. Central to this legal confrontation are attributed to noted computer scientist Joseph Bates, whose professional history spans various prominent universities and the establishment of Singular with the intent to market his advanced computing architectures.

Details of Alleged Infringement

Singular Computing's relationship with Google reportedly dates back to interactions between the two from 2010 to 2014. During this period, under a nondisclosure agreement, Bates disclosed several technologies to Google, clearly indicating protections. Singular Computing alleges that Google integrated Bates' designs into its second and third-generation TPUs without proper authorization or licensing agreements. The crux of the patents involves a computer architecture capable of executing an abundance of low-precision calculations, a requirement for AI applications which can tolerate such precision levels.

TPUs, which Google unveiled in 2016, are specialized hardware accelerators designed to enhance operations. They are largely utilized within Google's cloud services to bolster the functionality of products like Gmail, Google Maps, and YouTube. Currently in their fifth-generation, TPUs serve as a key component in and inference workload, poised as alternatives to more common GPU technology.

Last month, Google unveiled a new, performance-centric Tensor Unit (TPU) known as the v5p, aiming to drastically reduce the time required to train large language models. Building upon the previously announced TPU v5e, the v5p offers an increase in computational capabilities transparently targeting the needs of more intensive AI workloads.

The Stakes and Court Proceedings

The patents at the heart of this dispute include US 8,407,273, along with 9,218,156 and 10,416,961, which detail subsequent advancements in the technology. Singular's suit in a Massachusetts federal court demands a substantial sum for damages, ranging from $1.6 billion to $5.19 billion, under the premise that Google willfully infringed on these patents.

In defense, Google's legal representatives have asserted that the TPUs were independently developed and that the individuals who worked on these had no contact with Bates or his conceptual designs. Moreover, Google has initiated a separate endeavor in a U.S. appeals court to challenge the validity of Singular's patents, effectively seeking to nullify the infringement complaint by undermining the legitimacy of the patents themselves.

As the case unfolds, observers and stakeholders in AI, cloud computing, and semiconductor industries are closely monitoring the proceedings, understanding the broader implications such a decision could have on the tech landscape. The outcome could potentially reshape the competitive dynamics and practices surrounding proprietary technology and its protection. The main trial, anticipated to extend over two weeks, could set new precedents in how innovative ideas and their execution are legally safeguarded in the increasingly pivotal field of AI acceleration hardware.

Luke Jones
Luke Jones
Luke has been writing about all things tech for more than five years. He is following Microsoft closely to bring you the latest news about Windows, Office, Azure, Skype, HoloLens and all the rest of their products.

Recent News