HomeWinBuzzer NewsEU Struggles to Find Common Ground on Generative AI Regulation

EU Struggles to Find Common Ground on Generative AI Regulation

EU AI Act regulation is delayed due to disagreements over the oversight of generative AI, including self-regulation versus hard rules.


The European Union's deliberations to regulate generative artificial intelligence technologies have reached an impasse, with lawmakers still divided on the framework for overseeing these systems. The proposed AI Act, a piece of intended to ensure the responsible development and use of AI, is at risk of being postponed indefinitely if consensus is not reached soon. Representatives from the European Parliament, the Council, and the European Commission are set to have final discussions on December 6, 2023, following preliminary negotiations on Friday.

Generative AI at the Center of Debate

At the heart of the debate are “” such as those developed by Microsoft-backed OpenAI. These advanced AI systems, trained on extensive data sets, have the capability to adapt and perform a multitude of tasks after learning from new data inputs. As the EU seeks to establish regulations, the size and influence of such models have become contentious points. While some policymakers have suggested a tiered system based on user numbers — with thresholds such as 45 million users signaling higher tiers — arguments persist that smaller models can pose similar risks.

Self-Regulation Versus Hard Rules

The discussion has been further complicated by differing opinions on the approach to regulation. France, Germany, and Italy have shown a preference for self-regulation by AI developers rather than prescriptive rules. This stance, initially proposed by France and supported by Italy and Germany during an October meeting, contrasts with concerns posted by EU Commissioner Thierry Breton, parliamentarians, and AI experts. They argue that self-regulation may not sufficiently address safety concerns associated with foundation models. Companies such as France's Mistral and Germany's Aleph Alpha, on the other hand, favor stricter rules for products rather than the underlying technology.

Industry and Researchers Seek Clarity

The ongoing uncertainty surrounding the AI Act is causing trepidation within the European AI industry. Stakeholders from businesses to researchers urge for resolution to facilitate planning for the upcoming year and beyond. The act's pending issues stretch beyond foundation models and include topics such as the definition of AI, impact assessments on fundamental rights, and exceptions for law enforcement and national security uses. Law enforcement's use of AI for biometric identification has notably emerged as another point of contention.

Should the current presidency of Spain fail to foster an agreement, Belgium, as the next holder of the EU presidency, will face a narrowing window to resolve the impasse before the upcoming European parliamentary elections. The stakes are high as Europe grapples with the complex realities of governing cutting-edge AI technologies.

Luke Jones
Luke Jones
Luke has been writing about all things tech for more than five years. He is following Microsoft closely to bring you the latest news about Windows, Office, Azure, Skype, HoloLens and all the rest of their products.

Recent News